The Pirates did not have a lot of success with their number ones in the late 90s and the start of the new century because of their emphasis of drafting pitchers. Those pitchers had trouble staying healthy. After a number of arm surgeries the Pirates have nothing to show for those draft picks. The recent history has seemed to change that and with Pedro Alvarez, Andrew McCutchen and their recent pick Jameson Taillon things are starting to look up for the franchise. They have also gotten a break out year from Neil Walker, who started his year as a catcher, but moved to third base to hasten his development. That didn’t work as he forgot how to hit, but once promoted to the major leagues he’s found himself in the .300 neighborhood, something he rarely saw when he was in the minor leagues.
2005
Andrew McCutchen OF -Myworld loves this guy. He can hit, plays good defense and he steals bases. The Pirates got their money’s worth when they signed him for $1.9 million. He is currently hitting .288, which is two points above his 2009 average. The only concern is that his slugging numbers have dropped quite a bit from the previous year.
2006
Brad Lincoln RHP - Brad got his first taste of the major leagues in 2010 after signing for $2,75 million. Prior to 2010 he hasn’t shone particularly impressive numbers. Pitching for AAA this year he was 6-2, 3.16 which earned him a promotion to the Pirates. With Pittsburgh he is 1-4, 6.57, so the transition has had its hiccups. Brad is one of many Pirate pitchers that had to have Tommy John surgery, forcing him to miss the 2007 season. As a pitcher drafted in the first round out of college he should already be established in the major leagues if not for the injury. Clayton Kershaw, Daniel Bard, Brandon Morrow and Tim Lincecum, other pitchers taken in the first round from the 2006 draft have certainly made an impact.
2007
Danny Moskos LHP -If you had to pick one of two players to build your franchise, Matt Wieters or Danny Moskos, which would you choose? The Pirates chose Moskos. Wieters is now a major league catcher with the Baltimore Orioles. Moskos has been moved to relief and is pitching in AAA International after having some success in the Eastern League (1.45). That success has not transferred to AAA (6.08). The selection of Moskos over Wieters was purely economic and sometimes you get what you pay for. Moskos fastball resides in the high 80s, but used to be in the mid-90s when the Pirates drafted him. He lost the stuff that he had when he was the number one pick and Pirate fans can only hope that he finds it so they can get something for this selection.
2008
Pedro Alvarez 3B - The Pirates did not go cheap with Pedro, picking the best player available and signing him for a $6 million bonus. While his defense has always been questioned, putting in doubt his ability to play long term at third base, he has reached the major leagues as a third baseman. But then Jim Thome was a third baseman for a couple years with the Cleveland Indians. Time will tell if it will last. He may not hit for average, but as was exhibited in his back to back two homer games in the major leagues he has tremendous power. He should be the Pirates RBI machine of the future, until he gets to free agency where the Yankees will finally grab him. After hitting .277 with 13 homeruns in AAA the Pirates finally chose to promote him where his average is .244 with seven homeruns in 36 games. In AAA he hit lefthanded pitching much better than righthanded (.323/261) but this has not been the case in the majors. He needs to improve on his .193 average against lefthanders.
2009
Tony Sanchez C - There are some that believe that this was another of those economical picks, especially since the Pirates also had a supplemental pick to sign. Tony signed for $2.5 million, which was a couple hundred thousand below the slot. He’s also done well from a production standpoint, hitting .309 last year at three different levels and hitting .314 in the Florida State League. He’s been out since late June with a broken jaw. Initially it was assessed that he would miss 6-8 weeks, but the latest report has him missing the rest of the season. At least it is not arm surgery.
Victor Black RHP - Their first ever supplemental pick for their failure to sign second round pick Tanner Scheppers. Normally, having more than one number one pick will usually mean shelling out large contracts, and as a small market team that is not the way the Pirates like to do things. After signing Sanchez for below slot, they signed Black for slot at $717,000. He throws hard, but does not have the stuff or future potential of Scheppers. His best fit may be the bullpen because outside of a mid-90s fastball his other pitchers are lacking. Black pitched well last year, finishing with a 3.45 ERA. This year has been a typical year for a Pirate pitcher. His season was delayed as he nursed an oblique injury and after two starts and a 9.64 ERA he was placed on the disabled list. He hasn’t been seen since.
Other Pirate Minor Leaguers
Zack Von Rosenberg RHP - The Pirates drafted him in the sixth round and signed him for an above slot $1.2 million. He has made eight starts with unimpressive results, going 1-5, 4.65 with an opponent average of .290. At 6′5″ his low 90s fastball is expected to increase in velocity and with enough innings his curveball and change should gain enough consistency to be plus pitches. He is a big game winner, winning four straight high school state championship games in Louisiana.
Colton Cain LHP - An eighth rounder in 2009 who also signed an above slot bonus of over $1.15 million, he signed too late to pitch last year. He has recently joined Zack at State College and after two relief appearances pitched two solid starts. At two levels his ERA sits at 3.47 with an opponent average of .198. His fastball is low 90s with a curve having the potential to be a plus pitch. He needs to find a change to fit in his repertoire.
Brock Holt SS - He was making things look easy in the Florida State League, hitting .351, but a collision with a teammate has resulted in knee surgery. He will miss the remainder of the 2010 season.
Gift Ngoepe 2B - He grew up in South Africa, living with his mom in the clubhouse of a local baseball team. Now he is playing with the Pirates and hitting .271. You can read about him here: http://myworldofbaseball.com/wordpress/?p=2117
Dinesh Patel and Rinku Singh - No prospect list of the Pirates can be complete without an update of their two pitchers from India. You can read about them here: http://myworldofbaseball.com/wordpress/?p=722. While they are not really prospects, they are athletes and could develop. Patel has a 3.38 ERA in five bullpen appearances in the rookie Gulf Coast League, but the opposition is hitting him at a .348 clip. Singh is doing a bit better with a 1.80 ERA in seven appearances at the same level with an opposition average of .243. He also has more strikeouts than innings pitched, so as a prospect he may be separating himself from Patel. At 6′2″ Singh has more of a pitchers frame than the 5′11″ Patel. Singh also throws lefthanded, so he will be given more opportunities.